Rescue Your Soggy Compost with These Easy Fixes

Composting is a natural process that turns organic material into a nutrient-rich soil conditioner, perfect for gardening and farming. It’s a fantastic way to recycle organic waste such as vegetable peelings, kitchen scraps and yard waste, reducing the amount of waste that goes to landfill while creating a valuable resource for your garden.

However, for composting to be successful, it’s important to maintain a balance of elements within your compost pile.

One of the key factors in this balance is moisture. While perfect compost needs a certain level of moisture to facilitate the decomposition process, too much water can be detrimental. Overly wet, soggy compost can lead to a number of problems, including unpleasant odors and slowed decomposition.

Understanding how to manage the moisture levels in your compost heap is critical for achieving the best composting results. In the following sections, we will explore how to identify, fix, and prevent overly wet compost.

Managing A High Moisture Level in Your Compost

Compost is Too Wet

Identifying Overly Wet Compost

Recognizing the signs of overly wet compost is the first step in addressing the issue. When your compost is too wet, it may manifest a few noticeable symptoms that you should be aware of:

Bad Odor

One of the most common indicators of excessive moisture in your compost pile is a foul smell. Compost should have a fresh, earthy scent.

If it starts to smell rotten or like sewage, it’s a clear sign that it’s too damp. This happens because excess water creates an anaerobic environment, leading to the growth of bacteria that produce unpleasant odors.


Another tell-tale sign is the presence of leachate, a dark liquid that seeps from the bottom of your compost pile or bin.

While a small amount of moisture is necessary for the composting process, you shouldn’t see pools of water or damp patches around your compost area.

This leachate can contain harmful bacteria and nutrients that could potentially contaminate groundwater if not properly managed.

Poor Decomposition

If your compost pile seems to be decomposing at a slower rate than usual, it could be due to excessive moisture. When a compost pile is too wet, it can become compacted and oxygen-starved, slowing down the decomposition process.

You may notice that food waste and organic materials in the pile are not breaking down as they should, remaining recognizable for longer periods.

Presence of Pests

An overly wet compost pile can also attract unwanted pests. Creatures like rats and flies are attracted to the smells of rotting waste, which are more prevalent when your compost is too wet.

Unbalanced Texture

Lastly, the texture of your compost can indicate whether it’s too wet. Ideally, compost should feel like a wrung-out sponge – moist, but not dripping wet. If your compost feels slimy or you can squeeze water out of it, it’s likely too wet.

Reasons Your Compost is Too Wet

There are several reasons why your compost might be retaining too much moisture. Here, we’ll take a closer look at some of the common causes and how they contribute to overly wet compost.


One of the most straightforward reasons for a sopping wet compost pile is simply adding too much water. While compost needs moisture to break down organic matter, it’s easy to overdo it, especially if you’re new to composting. Remember, the goal is for your compost to be as damp as a wrung-out sponge, not soaking wet.

Insufficient Ventilation

A lack of air circulation can also lead to wet compost. This is because the microorganisms that help break down the compost need oxygen to survive. Without oxygen, anaerobic bacteria can take over and cause a foul odor and slow the decomposition process.

When there’s poor aeration, these microorganisms can’t do their job effectively, and the composting process slows down. As the compost breaks down slower, it retains water longer, leading to a wetter compost pile.

Imbalance of Green and Brown Materials

Your compost pile needs a good balance of green (nitrogen-rich) and brown (carbon-rich) materials to decompose properly. Green materials include things like vegetable scraps, coffee grounds, and fresh grass clippings. Brown materials consist of items like dry leaves, straw, and shredded newspaper.

If your compost pile has too many green materials, it can become overly wet. That’s because green materials contain a lot of moisture. On the other hand, brown materials help absorb excess moisture and add bulk to the pile, improving aeration. So, if your compost pile is too wet, it could be that you’re adding too many green materials and not enough browns.

If you have too many greens in your soggy compost pile, a quick solution is to add wood chips, dried leaves or even cardboard waste.

Lack of Drainage

Proper drainage is essential in a compost bin or pile. Without it, water can accumulate and make the compost overly wet. This could happen if your compost bin doesn’t have enough holes or if your compost pile is in a spot where water collects.

Weather Conditions

Lastly, the weather can play a big role in the moisture level of your compost. If you live in a particularly rainy area and your compost isn’t covered, it could easily become saturated with water. Similarly, in areas with high humidity, your compost could absorb moisture from the air and become overly wet.

How to Fix Wet Compost

If you find that your compost is too wet, don’t worry. It’s a problem that can be fixed with a few simple steps. Here’s what you can do:

Adding Dry Browns

Simple solution! One of the quickest ways to fix a wet compost pile is by adding more brown materials. As mentioned earlier, these are carbon-rich items like dried leaves, straw, peat moss, shredded newspaper or cardboard.

These materials help to absorb excess moisture and create air pockets in the compost, improving aeration. Add enough browns until the compost reaches the consistency of a wrung-out sponge.

Turning the Compost

Turning the compost helps to distribute moisture evenly and introduces much-needed oxygen into the mix. Rotate the mature compost in the center of the pile with the dry materials near the top and outsides.

Use a garden fork or a compost aerator to turn your compost pile, bringing the wet ingredients from the center to the outside and the drier material from the outside to the center. This should be done regularly, especially when trying to correct a moisture problem.

Improving Compost Bin Design

If your compost bin is the issue, consider making some changes to its design. Ensure it has adequate ventilation and drainage to prevent water from accumulating. This could mean drilling more holes in a plastic bin or raising a compost pile off the ground on a pallet.

Using a Compost Cover

To prevent rainwater from saturating your compost, use a cover. This can be as simple as a tarp or a piece of wood. Just make sure it still allows for air circulation.

Balancing Green and Brown Materials

Going forward, pay close attention to the balance of green and brown materials you add to your compost. A good rule of thumb is to aim for a 3:1 mix (3 parts brown to 1 part green), but you can adjust this based on your specific conditions and needs. If you notice your compost getting too wet, add more browns.

Preventing Overly Wet Compost

Preventing your compost from becoming overly wet is better than having to fix it. Here are some steps you can take to ensure your compost maintains the ideal moisture level:

Proper Watering Techniques

When adding water to your compost, do so sparingly. It’s better to add a little at a time and check the moisture level, rather than dousing it all at once. Remember, your compost should feel like a wrung-out sponge – moist, but not wet.

Maintaining Ideal Compost Material Ratio

Strive to maintain the right balance of green and brown materials in your good compost pile. A good rule of thumb is a 3 parts brown to 1 part green mix, but adjust as necessary based on your specific composting conditions. If you live in a wet climate or notice your compost is consistently too wet, consider adding more browns to help absorb excess moisture.

Using a Compost Cover

A compost cover can be a simple and effective way to control the amount of rainwater that gets into your compost pile. Just make sure the cover allows for sufficient air circulation. A piece of wood, a tarp, or a specialized compost bin lid can all work well.

Regularly Turning Your Compost

Regularly turning your compost helps to distribute moisture evenly, prevents compaction, and introduces oxygen, which aids in the decomposition process. Aim to turn your compost pile once a week, or more often if you notice it’s becoming too wet. A compost tumbler makes this super easy.

Choosing the Right Location

If possible, choose a location for your compost pile that doesn’t collect water. A slightly elevated spot can help ensure any excess water drains away from your compost.

Benefits of Properly Managed Compost

When you manage your compost properly, including maintaining the right moisture level, you unlock a multitude of benefits. Here are some of the key advantages:

Enhanced Soil Fertility

Properly composted organic material is rich in nutrients that plants need to thrive. By adding this finished compost to your garden soil, you can significantly improve its fertility. This results in healthier, stronger plants and a more productive garden.

Reduced Waste

Composting is an effective way to reduce the amount of waste that ends up in landfills. By composting your kitchen scraps and yard waste, you’re not only creating a valuable resource for your garden, but you’re also doing your part to reduce waste and conserve landfill space.

Improved Soil Structure

Compost improves the structure of the soil by increasing its ability to hold water and air, and promoting the growth of beneficial microorganisms. This leads to healthier root systems and stronger plants.

Cost Savings

By making your own compost, you can save money on store-bought soil amendments and fertilizers. Plus, because compost improves the health and productivity of your garden, you can save money on produce too.

Environmental Impact

Composting has significant environmental benefits. It reduces the need for chemical fertilizers, decreases methane emissions from landfills, and helps sequester carbon in the soil, which can help combat climate change.

Educational Opportunities

For families, composting can provide an excellent educational opportunity. It’s a practical way to teach children about nature, the cycle of life, and the importance of recycling and waste reduction.


Managing the moisture level in your compost pile is a crucial aspect of successful composting. Overly wet compost can lead to a host of problems, including bad odors, slow decomposition, and unwanted pests.

Recognizing the signs of excess moisture and understanding its causes are the first steps towards addressing the issue.

Overwatering, insufficient ventilation, an imbalance of green and brown materials, lack of drainage, and weather conditions can all contribute to overly wet compost and are actually an all too common problem.

However, by adding brown dry ingredients, turning the compost, improving compost bin design, using a compost cover, and balancing green and brown materials, you can fix a wet compost pile.

Prevention is always better than cure. Proper watering techniques, maintaining an ideal compost material ratio, using a compost cover, regularly turning your compost, and choosing the right location can help prevent your compost from becoming overly wet in the first place.

Properly managed compost brings a multitude of benefits, from enhanced soil fertility and reduced waste to cost savings and educational opportunities.

Despite the challenges, the effort put into managing your compost’s moisture level will result in a rich, healthy soil conditioner that your garden will love.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *